Home / Shelter Island, NY / Theater

Shelter Island, NY Theater Tickets

690 upcoming theater shows · from $44 all-in · 17 venues

✓ All-in pricing — no service or booking fees✓ 100% Buyer Guarantee

Top venues:Theatre Three35Gateway Playhouse35Ivoryton Playhouse32Shubert Theater22Palace Theater10

Date
Price
Venue
Sort by
Top 16 of 690 events · filter to narrow
Top 16 of 690 events · filter to narrow
AUG6THU · 2:00 PMCome From AwayIvoryton Playhouse · 32 datesFrom $508Find Tickets →AUG7FRI · 8:00 PMCome From AwayGateway Playhouse · 35 datesFrom $190Find Tickets →SEP16WED · 7:00 PMWorld Ballet Company: Swan LakeKlein Memorial AuditoriumFrom $88Find Tickets →OCT1THU · 7:00 PMThe WizShubert Theater · 5 datesFrom $84Find Tickets →OCT27TUE · 7:00 PMThe Price Is Right - Live Stage ShowPalace TheaterFrom $129Find Tickets →NOV7SAT · 7:00 PMA Christmas CarolTheatre Three · 35 datesFrom $72Find Tickets →NOV18WED · 7:00 PMHow The Grinch Stole ChristmasShubert Theater · 7 datesFrom $74Find Tickets →DEC10THU · 7:30 PMCirque Du Soleil - Twas The Night BeforeToyota Oakdale Theatre · 8 datesFrom $66Find Tickets →DEC11FRI · 7:30 PMCirque Dreams: HolidazeMohegan Sun Arena · 3 datesFrom $76Find Tickets →DEC12SAT · 1:30 PMThe Eastern Connecticut Ballet: The NutcrackerGarde Arts Center · 3 datesFrom $75Find Tickets →

Price intelligence · updated daily

How much are Shelter Island theater tickets?

Shelter Island theater tickets currently start at $44 all-in, with a typical seat around $102 and a range of $44–$508. 11 are available under $50.

$44cheapest right now — Beetlejuice - The Musical
$102typical price
11under $50

Where prices land

Under $250%
$25–$502%
$50–$10047%
$100–$25048%
$250+3%

48% of Shelter Island theater tickets land in the $100–$250 range, 11 under $50, and the cheapest right now is $44.

Shelter Island theater ticket prices & availability

There are 690 theater shows on the Shelter Island theater calendar right now — all-in prices open at $44, with most seats around $102. Budget picks exist too — 11 under $50. Most of the action is at Theatre Three and Gateway Playhouse, with more dates at Ivoryton Playhouse.

The cheapest theater ticket in the Shelter Island area right now is Beetlejuice - The Musical, from $44 all-in. Prices are shown with no fees added, and each order is protected by the 100% Buyer Guarantee.

More Shelter Island tickets

Shelter Island Concert503 events · from $13Shelter Island Comedy182 events · from $22Shelter Island Sports156 events · from $7Shelter Island Family61 events · from $20All Shelter Island eventsConcerts, sports & theater together
No hidden fees. Shelter Island theater tickets on this page are priced all-in — no service fees waiting at checkout.How our pricing works →

Shelter Island theater tickets — frequently asked

Are Shelter Island theater ticket prices all-in?

There's no service fee, booking fee or delivery fee on any Shelter Island theater listing — the number you see is the ticket price, and nothing is added at checkout. The one exception is sales tax, in the states that tax ticket sales; it's shown at checkout before you pay.

Which venues host theater shows in and around Shelter Island?

Most theater shows are at Theatre Three, Gateway Playhouse, and Ivoryton Playhouse — 17 venues in and around Shelter Island have upcoming theater shows.

What's the cheapest theater ticket in the Shelter Island area?

Right now the cheapest is Beetlejuice - The Musical, from $44 all-in, and 11 dates are under $50.

How many theater shows are coming up in and around Shelter Island?

There are 690 theater shows on the Shelter Island schedule, and the finder above always shows the latest.

Is it safe to buy theater tickets for Shelter Island events here?

It is — we work only with licensed, professional sellers, and every order carries our 100% Buyer Guarantee: valid tickets, delivered in time, or your money back.

How quickly do Shelter Island theater tickets arrive?

Most are electronic — mobile transfer or instant download — and arrive within minutes to hours of purchase. The listing shows the delivery method before you buy.

Are Shelter Island theater tickets backed by a guarantee?

Yes, end to end. The 100% Buyer Guarantee protects every purchase: real tickets, on time, or your money back.