Home / Middletown, NY / Theater

Middletown, NY Theater Tickets

312 upcoming theater shows · from $32 all-in · 18 venues

✓ All-in pricing — no service or booking fees✓ 100% Buyer Guarantee

Top venues:Palace Theatre New York City210Mayo Performing Arts Center25White Plains Performing Arts Center17Samuel H. Scripps Theater Center at Hudson Valley Shakespeare16Bergen Performing Arts Center14

Date
Price
Venue
Sort by
Showing 61 of 312 events · filter to narrow
Showing 61 of 312 events · filter to narrow
SEP8TUE · 7:00 PMThe Lost Boys - The MusicalPalace Theatre New York CityFrom $90Find Tickets →SEP9WED · 2:00 PMThe Lost Boys - The MusicalPalace Theatre New York CityFrom $106Find Tickets →SEP9WED · 7:30 PMThe Lost Boys - The MusicalPalace Theatre New York CityFrom $90Find Tickets →OCT16FRI · 7:30 PMThe Improvised Shakespeare CompanySouth Orange Performing Arts CenterFrom $81Find Tickets →OCT17SAT · 7:00 PMJohn Cusack - Screening of High FidelityBergen Performing Arts CenterFrom $107Find Tickets →OCT17SAT · 7:30 PMThe Improvised Shakespeare CompanySouth Orange Performing Arts CenterFrom $81Find Tickets →OCT19MON · 3:00 PMThe Lost Boys - MusicalPalace Theatre New York CityFrom $206Find Tickets →OCT24SAT · 8:00 PMBat Out Of Helloween - Celebrating Meat LoafSugar Loaf Performing Arts CenterFrom $79Find Tickets →OCT24SAT · 9:00 PMThe Rocky Horror Picture Show - FilmTarrytown Music HallFrom $65Find Tickets →OCT25SUN · 7:00 PMThe Vampire CircusBergen Performing Arts CenterFrom $71Find Tickets →

Price intelligence · updated through the day

How much are Middletown theater tickets?

Middletown theater tickets currently start at $32 all-in; the median date gets in around $94, and the range is $32–$206. 7 dates get in under $50.

$32cheapest right now — A Peter Pan Christmas
$94typical price
7under $50

Where prices land

Under $250%
$25–$502%
$50–$10072%
$100–$25026%
$250+0%

72% of Middletown theater dates get in between $50 and $100, 7 under $50.

Theater & Broadway shows in Middletown: what's on

Theater shows near Middletown: 312 theater shows within a short drive, none of them in Middletown itself; most are in New York, about 50 miles away (Palace Theatre New York City).

More Middletown tickets

Middletown Concert319 events · from $23Middletown Sports195 events · from $10Middletown Family & more180 events · from $45Middletown Comedy65 events · from $45All Middletown eventsConcerts, sports & theater together

Frequently asked

Which venues host theater shows in and around Middletown?

Palace Theatre New York City (210 upcoming), Mayo Performing Arts Center (25 upcoming), and White Plains Performing Arts Center (17 upcoming) lead; 18 venues in the area have upcoming theater shows.

What's the cheapest theater ticket in the Middletown area?

A Peter Pan Christmas is currently the cheapest get-in, $32 all-in, alongside 6 other dates under $50. No service, booking or delivery fees; sales tax applies in some states and is shown before you pay.

Is it safe to buy theater tickets for Middletown events here?

Yes. This is an independent resale marketplace: tickets come from licensed, professional sellers, prices can sit above or below face value, and the 100% Buyer Guarantee backs every order: valid tickets, delivered in time, or your money back.