Home / Butler, IN / Theater

Butler, IN Theater Tickets

60 upcoming theater shows · from $55 all-in · 4 venues

✓ All-in pricing — no service or booking fees✓ 100% Buyer Guarantee

Top venues:Blue Gate Music Hall50Blue Gate Performing Arts Center7Embassy Theatre2

Date
Price
Venue
Sort by
60 events · one card per show
60 events · one card per show
SEP1TUE · 4:00 PMSensational 60s RevueBlue Gate Music Hall · 4 datesFrom $57Find Tickets →SEP1TUE · 7:00 PMLove Comes Softly - The MusicalBlue Gate Music Hall · 28 datesFrom $72Find Tickets →SEP4FRI · 1:00 PMLove Comes SoftlyBlue Gate Music Hall · 16 datesFrom $72Find Tickets →SEP9WED · 4:00 PMLove Comes Softly the MusicalBlue Gate Music Hall · 2 datesFrom $72Find Tickets →OCT22THU · 7:30 PMWheel of FortuneClyde TheatreFrom $62Find Tickets →DEC7MON · 7:00 PMNutcracker! Magical Christmas BalletBlue Gate Performing Arts CenterFrom $76Find Tickets →DEC16WED · 7:00 PMA Charlie Brown Christmas - Live on StageBlue Gate Performing Arts CenterGreat priceFrom $55Find Tickets →DEC17THU · 7:00 PMDerek HoughBlue Gate Performing Arts Center · 2 datesFrom $143Find Tickets →SEP11FRI · 1:00 PMLove Comes Softly - The MusicalBlue Gate Performing Arts Center · 3 datesNo tickets right nowCheck back →JAN12TUE · 7:30 PMShucked - MusicalEmbassy Theatre · 2 datesNo tickets right nowCheck back →

Price intelligence · updated daily

How much are Butler theater tickets?

Butler theater tickets currently start at $55 all-in, with a typical seat around $72 and a range of $55–$143.

$55cheapest right now — A Charlie Brown Christmas - Live…
$72typical price

Where prices land

Under $250%
$25–$500%
$50–$10096%
$100–$2504%
$250+0%

96% of Butler theater tickets land in the $50–$100 range, and the cheapest right now is $55.

Theater & Broadway shows in Butler — prices & availability

Butler, IN has 60 upcoming theater shows, with all-in tickets starting at $55 and most landing around $72. Blue Gate Music Hall, Blue Gate Performing Arts Center, and Embassy Theatre carry most of the theater calendar here.

The lowest get-in on the current slate is A Charlie Brown Christmas - Live on Stage at $55, fees included. Every price on this page is the full ticket price — no service or booking fees — and every order carries our 100% Buyer Guarantee.

More Butler tickets

Butler Concert83 events · from $14Butler Sports36 events · from $20All Butler eventsConcerts, sports & theater together
No hidden fees. Butler theater tickets on this page are priced all-in — the price you see is the ticket price.How our pricing works →

Butler theater tickets — frequently asked

Are Butler theater ticket prices all-in?

Yes — and there are no fees to include. Every Butler theater price here is the full ticket price, with no service, booking, or delivery fee added at checkout. Sales tax applies in some states and is shown before you pay.

Which venues host theater shows in and around Butler?

The busiest right now are Blue Gate Music Hall (50 upcoming), Blue Gate Performing Arts Center (7 upcoming), and Embassy Theatre (2 upcoming) — 4 venues in the area have upcoming theater shows.

What's the cheapest theater ticket in the Butler area?

A Charlie Brown Christmas - Live on Stage is currently the cheapest get-in, $55 with fees included.

How many theater shows are coming up in and around Butler?

60 upcoming theater shows are listed for Butler right now — the list above updates in real time.

Is it safe to buy theater tickets for Butler events here?

Yes. This is an independent resale marketplace: tickets come from licensed, professional sellers, prices can sit above or below face value, and the 100% Buyer Guarantee backs every order.

How quickly do Butler theater tickets arrive?

Quickly, in most cases: electronic delivery (mobile transfer or instant download) typically lands within minutes to hours. Each listing states its method up front.

Are Butler theater tickets backed by a guarantee?

They are — each order carries the 100% Buyer Guarantee: authentic tickets that arrive on time, or a full refund.