Bay Shore, NY Theater Tickets

9,341 upcoming theater shows · from $7 all-in · 115 venues

✓ All-in pricing — no service or booking fees✓ 100% Buyer Guarantee

Top venues:Westside Theatre Upstairs576 Winter Garden Theatre - New York386 Magic Mike Live - New York375 New Amsterdam Theatre337 Lyric Theatre - New York309

Date

Price

Venue

Sort by

146 events · 9,341 dates · filter to narrow

SEP7MON · 7:00 PMChicago - The MusicalAmbassador TheatreFrom $137Find Tickets →SEP7MON · 7:00 PMDrunk Shakespeare - Romeo and JulietThe Ruby TheatreFrom $131Find Tickets →SEP7MON · 7:00 PMSix - The MusicalLena Horne TheatreGreat priceFrom $67Find Tickets →SEP7MON · 7:00 PMThe Play That Goes WrongNew World Stages: Stage 4 · 2 datesFrom $136Find Tickets →SEP8TUE · 7:00 PMWickedGershwin TheatreFrom $111Find Tickets →SEP8TUE · 7:00 PMThe Lion KingMinskoff TheatreFrom $133Find Tickets →SEP8TUE · 7:00 PMHamilton - The MusicalRichard Rodgers TheatreFrom $256Find Tickets →SEP8TUE · 7:00 PMHarry Potter and the Cursed ChildLyric Theatre - New YorkFrom $177Find Tickets →SEP8TUE · 7:00 PMThe OutsidersBernard B. Jacobs TheaterFrom $131Find Tickets →SEP8TUE · 7:00 PMMaybe Happy EndingBelasco TheatreFrom $142Find Tickets →

Price intelligence · updated through the day

How much are Bay Shore theater tickets?

Bay Shore theater tickets currently start at $7 all-in, with a typical seat around $139 and a range of $7–$1,224. 130 dates get in under $50.

$7cheapest right now — Asha Banks

$139typical price

130under $50

Where prices land

Under $25<1%

$25–$501%

$50–$10018%

$100–$25072%

$250+9%

72% of Bay Shore theater dates get in between $100 and $250, 130 under $50.

Theater & Broadway shows in Bay Shore — prices & availability

Theater shows near Bay Shore: 9,341 theater shows within a short drive, 1 of them in Bay Shore itself; most are in New York (Westside Theatre Upstairs and Winter Garden Theatre - New York), about 40 miles away.

More Bay Shore tickets

Bay Shore Concert2,001 events · from $11 Bay Shore Sports653 events · from $10 Bay Shore Comedy563 events · from $22 Bay Shore Family & more681 events · from $15 All Bay Shore eventsConcerts, sports & theater together

Frequently asked

Which venues host theater shows in and around Bay Shore?

Westside Theatre Upstairs (576 upcoming), Winter Garden Theatre - New York (386 upcoming), and Magic Mike Live - New York (375 upcoming) lead; 115 venues in the area have upcoming theater shows.

What's the cheapest theater ticket in the Bay Shore area?

Right now the cheapest is Asha Banks, from $7 all-in, one of 130 dates under $50. No service, booking or delivery fees; sales tax applies in some states and is shown before you pay.

Is it safe to buy theater tickets for Bay Shore events here?

It is. We work only with licensed, professional sellers, prices follow supply and demand, and every order carries our 100% Buyer Guarantee: valid tickets, delivered in time, or your money back.